Football managers getting sanctioned by the FA for speaking out against refs
The Manchester United manager, Sir Alex Ferguson, and his assistant (Carlos Quieroz) are getting hauled before a kangaroo court at the FA for criticizing the referee in their FA Cup match against Portsmouth a few weeks ago, which Portsmouth won to the shock and amazement of many.
The broader context for all this is an ongoing ‘despair’ (forgive my cynicism) of many politicians, managers and players that referees are not getting due respect. This stands in stark contrast to rugby, in which, by and large, the referee is a near-deity, whose word is very much final, and is very rarely second-guessed by players (unlike football where a significant proportion of decisions result in the ref being surrounded and harassed - interrupting the game and angering all involved). It’s understandable that a referee should not be aggressed midgame by players. But a manager can have nothing but sympathy for his players if he can’t air his thoughts once the match has ended.
I’m interested in the censure of managers and players once the game has ended. What’s the reason for this? The moment the manager turns away from the TV camera, seething but biting his tongue, he’s just going to head into the dressing room and slate the referee. In the pub, the audience will be ostracising the referee. So both the managers, players and audience are having a go. Banning a manager from publicly expressing his anger at a poor refereeing decision is just a charade! Who the hell does it protect? If it’s aimed at instilling a culture of respect, it fails because of the social context in which sport is watched - the audience, future players, all bounce anti-ref rants off one another whether a manager has a go or not.
Maybe if we allowed managers to air the team’s anger after the match, the players wouldn’t feel the need to harangue a ref during it. A manager wouldn’t sympathise with his players - who often get yellow-carded for their trouble (or get a red! e.g. Javier Mascherano last week) - he could have a go, telling them it’s his job to have a go after the match, their job is to play during it.
It’s worth a try, anyway - the censorship of managers is just a pointless charade. Managers would frequently criticise a ref if allowed, but that very fact would stop the media making such a huge story out of it. At the moment, they pounce and prey on it. Every post-match interview will ask a manager what he thought of the ref, despite knowing that the manager can’t say anything bad! Because when he does, it gets splashed across the headlines, and rehashed endlessly until the ensuing disciplinary matter is closed. If it was a common occurrence it wouldn’t be ‘new’ and wouldn’t make the ‘news’.
Related:
- Conversation platforms will make blogs increasingly redundant
- There are many reasons why people blog. Some, like mine, are experiments in self-expression and a historical log of experiences, opinions and discoveries of personal interest. They’re (primarily text-based) pedestals for the development of a digital ‘sculpture’ of your identity. Visitors are attracted both to explore your unique identity and points of view, and to read and participate in the conversations your posts have sparked. Communities are environments that foster identities. This happens when you abandon anonymity and let people associate your comments (conversational inputs) with a name that they can become familiar with. The easier it is for people to associate your previous comments with your current one, the easier it is for them to understand where you’re coming from, who you are. Identity is all about adding context to your actions. There are lots of other ways of adding context: an avatar (or even a real photo of you); even broader identity context like your facebook profile, a link to your homepage, to other places you’re active – Twitter, other sites, etc. What Disqus, IntenseDebate, MyBlogLog, SezWho etc do is provide a really compelling, web-wide context to your actions on a site: e.g. when I comment here, you...
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
Add New Comment
Thanks. Your comment is awaiting approval by a moderator.
Do you already have an account? Log in and claim this comment.
Add New Comment
Trackbacks